eCommerce Email Marketing: Shopify Email vs Klaviyo?

Today’s guest post is by Cassidy Thiesen, our resident creative director for eCommerce brands. Cassidy helps retailers build brands that attract customers, drive sales, and grow sustainably online and in-store.

---

If you’re a product-based business using Shopify, email marketing is one of the most powerful ways to stay connected with your customers and drive repeat sales. But when it comes to choosing an email platform, many retailers find themselves deciding between two options: Shopify Email vs Klaviyo.

Both tools allow you to send campaigns and communicate with your customers, but they serve very different purposes depending on the stage of your business and the level of email marketing strategy you want to implement as a retail brand. 

In this blog post, I’ll walk you through the major differences between Shopify Email vs Klaviyo, when each tool makes sense, and why I typically recommend Klaviyo for eCommerce email marketing.

What is Shopify Email?

Before diving into the major differences between Shopify Email and Klaviyo, let’s get clear on what each of them actually is – starting with Shopify Email!

Shopify Email is Shopify’s built-in email marketing tool designed for merchants who want a simple way to send emails directly from their store dashboard.

Because it’s native to Shopify, it connects seamlessly with your store data, which means you can easily send emails to customers based on things like purchase history, abandoned carts, or general customer lists without needing a third-party platform.

And I’ll admit – that’s one of the biggest pros to Shopify email! It’s simple and already built into your Shopify POS, so it is very attractive to retailers. 

The easy set up doesn’t require a lot of technical knowledge, which is another thing that makes it so appealing to retailers. You can create emails using pre-built templates, add products directly from your store catalog, and send campaigns to your audience in just a few clicks.

For many small businesses, Shopify Email works well for basic newsletters, simple promotional campaigns, store announcements, and smaller email lists.

Another benefit of Shopify Email is cost as this platform offers a certain number of free emails each month and relatively low pricing beyond that, which can make it a budget-friendly option for businesses just starting their email marketing journey.

However, while Shopify Email is simple and convenient, it does have limitations, especially when compared to more robust email marketing platforms – we’ll get to those in a minute!

What is Klaviyo?

Comparatively, Klaviyo is one of the most powerful email and SMS marketing platforms specifically built for eCommerce brands.

Unlike Shopify Email, Klaviyo is designed to support advanced marketing strategies through deep customer data, automation, segmentation, and behavioral targeting.

For retail brands looking to grow their customer lifetime value and build stronger relationships with shoppers, this level of functionality can make a huge difference!

With Klaviyo, you can create highly personalized marketing campaigns based on customer behavior, such as browsing activity, past purchases, product preferences, or how engaged someone is with your emails.

And that’s one of the main reasons that my top recommendation for email marketing for most retail brands is Klaviyo! Some of the most powerful features Klaviyo offers include:

• Advanced email and SMS automation
• Detailed customer segmentation
• Predictive analytics
• Revenue tracking from campaigns
• Highly customizable email templates
• Dynamic product recommendations

This means your email marketing can go far beyond just basic newsletters and instead you can create entire customer journeys that automatically guide shoppers from first purchase to loyal repeat buyer!

Shopify Email vs. Klaviyo: The Major Differences

While Klaviyo is often my top choice for eCommerce email marketing, I really try to stay unbiased with my recommendations because here’s what I know to be true when it comes to business: there’s rarely a one-size-fits-all tool.

And I would rather you have allll the facts so you can make the decision that’s truly best for you. 

So now that you have a better understanding of what Shopify Email and Klaviyo even are, we can get into the major differences between the two! 

When comparing Shopify Email vs Klaviyo, the biggest difference comes down to simplicity versus strategy.

Shopify Email focuses on giving merchants a quick and easy way to send emails, while Klaviyo focuses on giving brands a comprehensive marketing platform designed to drive long-term revenue.

Here are some of the major differences between the two:

Automation Capabilities

Shopify Email offers basic automation options like welcome emails or abandoned cart reminders.

Klaviyo, on the other hand, allows you to build complex automated flows based on customer behavior, which includes sequences like:

• Welcome series
• Post-purchase follow-ups
• Product replenishment reminders
• Win-back campaigns
• VIP customer flows
• Browse abandonment emails

These automated flows can run continuously in the background, generating revenue without requiring constant manual effort.

Customer Segmentation

Segmentation is one of the biggest advantages Klaviyo has over Shopify Email and this can be a HUGE advantage for you as a retailer!

Shopify Email allows you to send emails to basic customer groups, but Klaviyo lets you create incredibly detailed audience segments based on things like:

• Purchase frequency
• Average order value
• Product categories purchased
• Website activity
• Engagement with previous emails

This means you can send much more relevant emails to your customers, which typically leads to higher open rates, more clicks, and more sales – which is typically the goal that people have with eCommerce email marketing!

Data and Reporting

While Shopify Email provides basic reporting metrics like opens and clicks, Klaviyo offers far more detailed insights into how your email marketing is performing.

With Klaviyo, you can track things like:

• Revenue generated by specific campaigns
• Customer lifetime value
• Predictive purchasing behavior
• Engagement trends across your audience

For retailers who want to make data-driven marketing decisions, this deeper level of reporting is incredibly valuable.

Customization and Design

Both platforms allow you to design branded emails, but Klaviyo offers far more flexibility when it comes to customization.

With Klaviyo, you can create highly tailored email experiences using dynamic content, product recommendations, and personalized messaging based on customer behavior.

This makes it easier to build emails that feel less like mass marketing and more like curated shopping experiences, which is a huge trust builder with your customers and typically keeps them coming back for more!

Cost Considerations

One area where Shopify Email does have an advantage is pricing.

Shopify Email is generally more affordable, especially for small lists. Klaviyo pricing increases as your list grows because it’s based on the number of contacts in your account.

However, many retailers find that Klaviyo quickly pays for itself through the additional revenue generated by advanced automation and segmentation!

Why I Recommend Klaviyo vs Shopify Email for eCommerce Email Marketing 

While both platforms have their place, I almost always recommend Klaviyo over Shopify Email for retail brands that are serious about growing their business.

Because here’s the thing: eCommerce email marketing isn’t just about sending newsletters. 

While newsletters can and often should have a place in your retail business, effective email marketing is also about creating systems that nurture relationships with your customers and encourage repeat purchases.

Klaviyo makes this possible by giving you access to deeper data, smarter automation, and more advanced marketing tools!

For example, instead of sending one general email to your entire list, Klaviyo allows you to send highly targeted messages like:

• A product restock alert to customers who previously viewed an item
• A replenishment reminder for consumable products
• A VIP offer for your most loyal customers
• A win-back email for customers who haven’t purchased in several months

These types of personalized experiences can dramatically increase customer lifetime value and overall store revenue. For independent retailers trying to compete with larger brands, this kind of strategic email marketing can be a major advantage!

Klaviyo Email Marketing Services for Shopify Users

So, there you have it! The major differences between Shopify email vs Klaviyo for eCommerce email marketing and the reason I typically recommend Klaviyo instead!

With that said, however, Klaviyo is a powerful tool when you set it up correctly and strategically. To really get the most out of it, it’s important to build automated workflows, segment your audience appropriately, design branded templates, and optimize your campaigns for conversions. 

Oftentimes, retailers find that part of the process confusing and time-consuming, which is where I can come in!

As a Shopify website designer and eCommerce email marketing strategist, I help retail brands implement Klaviyo in a way that supports their entire online ecosystem, not just their email marketing.

Overall, if you’re currently deciding between Shopify Email vs Klaviyo, my hope is that this blog post gives you some clarity on which route to take! And if you’re ready to start using Klaviyo for your email marketing efforts, but just aren’t sure how to get started, I’d love to connect.

CLICK HERE to learn more about my Klaviyo email marketing services, and together we can build an eCommerce email marketing strategy that works seamlessly with your Shopify store and supports the long-term growth of your retail brand!

---

Visit Cassidy’s profile: